The Plucky Squire Review

In the vast library of action-adventure games, it’s rare to find a title that literally jumps off the page. Enter The Plucky Squire, a 2024 release from indie studio All Possible Futures and publisher Devolver Digital, which invites players into a whimsical tale where the boundaries between 2D storybooks and the 3D world blur in the most delightful ways.

This charming escapade follows Jot, a courageous squire who discovers that life exists beyond the illustrated confines of his storybook. With a narrative that seamlessly transitions between the flat, colorful pages of a children’s tale and the three-dimensional space of the real world, The Plucky Squire offers a fresh twist on the classic hero’s journey.

Critics have lauded the game for its inventive mechanics and enchanting art style. IGN praised it as “a beautiful storybook adventure filled with brilliant wordplay-packed puzzles and clever dimension-hopping mechanics.” Rock Paper Shotgun highlighted its “charming, and occasionally brilliant, 2D to 3D platforming and puzzling.”

As we delve deeper into this review, we’ll explore how The Plucky Squire crafts its narrative, engages players with its gameplay mechanics, and whether it successfully balances its ambitious ideas throughout the adventure.

Setting and Story

In The Plucky Squire, players are transported into the enchanting world of Mojo—a vibrant, storybook realm brimming with color and creativity. Ruled by the benevolent Queen Chroma, Mojo is a land where imagination knows no bounds, encompassing locales from the quaint Inkwood Village to the murky Sonnet Swamps and the towering peaks of Trarrg Mountain.

The narrative centers on Jot, the titular plucky squire and perennial hero of Mojo’s tales, whose valor has repeatedly thwarted the nefarious schemes of the evil wizard Humgrump. However, upon realizing his predestined role as the perpetual loser in these stories, Humgrump takes drastic action—he banishes Jot from the pages of his own storybook, thereby altering the narrative’s course and casting a shadow over Mojo’s once-harmonious existence.

Ejected from the familiar two-dimensional confines of his illustrated world, Jot finds himself in the expansive, uncharted territory of the three-dimensional real world. This unexpected exile propels him on a quest not only to restore the story’s original happy ending but also to rescue his friends from Humgrump’s dark influence. Along the way, Jot discovers the ability to traverse between the 2D pages of his book and the 3D realm beyond, a skill that becomes instrumental in solving the myriad puzzles and challenges that lie ahead. ​

The narrative is further enriched by the inclusion of Jot’s companions: Violet, a trainee witch and artist whose creative prowess aids in overcoming artistic obstacles; and Thrash, a mountain troll and heavy metal drummer whose rhythmic skills provide a unique approach to confronting challenges. Together, this trio embodies the game’s underlying themes of friendship, creativity, and the timeless struggle between good and evil. ​

By weaving a tale that seamlessly blends classic storybook charm with innovative dimensional shifts, The Plucky Squire crafts a narrative that is both heartwarming and thought-provoking, inviting players to ponder the power of storytelling and the courage required to rewrite one’s destiny.

Gameplay and Mechanics

The Plucky Squire offers a distinctive gameplay experience by seamlessly blending 2D and 3D environments, allowing players to navigate between the illustrated pages of a storybook and the tangible world beyond. This dynamic interplay serves as the foundation for a variety of puzzles and challenges that require creative thinking and adaptability.

Within the 2D realm of the storybook, the game adopts a classic top-down perspective reminiscent of traditional adventure titles. Players guide Jot through vibrant, hand-drawn landscapes, engaging in combat with whimsical foes and solving puzzles that often involve manipulating the book’s text and illustrations to alter the environment. For instance, rearranging words within the narrative can transform obstacles into pathways, adding a literary twist to the puzzle-solving elements.

Transitioning into the 3D world introduces a shift in gameplay dynamics. Here, Jot explores a child’s cluttered desk, interacting with everyday objects that become integral to his quest. This perspective shift not only diversifies the gameplay but also enriches the narrative by highlighting the contrast between the fantastical storybook setting and the mundane real world. The mechanics in this dimension involve platforming challenges and environmental puzzles that leverage the physicality of 3D space.

The game also features a series of inventive mini-games and boss encounters that further diversify the gameplay. These range from rhythm-based challenges to shooting galleries, each designed to test different skills and keep the experience fresh. While these segments are generally well-executed, some players may find certain mini-games to be less polished than the core gameplay, occasionally disrupting the overall pacing. ​

However, the game has been noted for its linear puzzle design and underutilization of its creative mechanics. While the concept of shifting between dimensions is innovative, some puzzles may feel straightforward, lacking the depth that could have been achieved with more complex integration of the game’s unique features.

In response to feedback regarding the game’s tutorialization, an update introduced a “streamlined mode” aimed at reducing excessive guidance and allowing for a more fluid gameplay experience. This mode minimizes interruptions and provides experienced players with greater autonomy, addressing earlier concerns about the game’s pacing.

Overall, The Plucky Squire delivers a charming and innovative gameplay experience that cleverly utilizes its dual-dimensional premise. While certain aspects could benefit from deeper development, the game’s creative mechanics and engaging world make it a noteworthy addition to the action-adventure genre.

Multiplayer and Replayability

The Plucky Squire is designed as a single-player experience, focusing on the personal journey of Jot and his companions. There is no cooperative or multiplayer mode available, a detail confirmed by the game’s listings on platforms like the Xbox Store, which categorize it strictly as a single-player title.

In terms of replayability, the game offers a linear narrative with a series of unique puzzles and mini-games that unfold as the story progresses. While the initial playthrough provides a charming and inventive experience, some players have noted that the game’s replay value is somewhat limited. For instance, revisiting earlier chapters to re-experience specific mini-games or puzzles can feel repetitive, as the game’s structure doesn’t significantly change upon subsequent playthroughs. ​

Additionally, the game’s relatively short length has been a point of discussion among players. Some have expressed that the concise duration, coupled with straightforward gameplay, may not justify the full price for those seeking a longer-term engagement.

However, it’s important to note that the quality of the experience during the initial playthrough has been praised for its creativity and charm. The game’s unique mechanics, such as transitioning between 2D and 3D environments and manipulating the storybook’s narrative, provide a fresh and engaging adventure that resonates with many players. ​

In summary, while The Plucky Squire may not offer extensive replayability or multiplayer features, its original concept and delightful execution make it a worthwhile experience for those seeking a unique, albeit brief, adventure.

Graphics and Sound

The Plucky Squire captivates players with its inventive fusion of 2D and 3D visuals, crafting a world that feels both nostalgic and refreshingly original. Within the storybook segments, the game showcases beautifully illustrated, hand-drawn art reminiscent of classic children’s literature. Each page bursts with vibrant colors and meticulous details, bringing the whimsical realm of Mojo to life. Transitions from these 2D illustrations to the 3D environments are executed seamlessly, revealing a tangible world filled with everyday objects that gain new significance through Jot’s diminutive perspective. This interplay between dimensions not only serves the narrative but also enriches the player’s visual experience.

The 3D environments are equally impressive, transforming mundane items like coffee mugs and stationery into towering landscapes and formidable obstacles. The art direction in these sections employs a playful use of scale and perspective, making the ordinary appear extraordinary. This design choice enhances the sense of adventure, as players navigate Jot through a world where a simple desk becomes an expansive playground.

Complementing the visual artistry is a delightful soundtrack that underscores the game’s whimsical tone. Each area within the game features its own distinct musical theme, ranging from traditional fantasy-inspired melodies in forested regions to heavier, rock-infused tracks during more intense sequences. This variety not only adds depth to each environment but also keeps the auditory experience fresh and engaging.

Sound effects are thoughtfully crafted to match the game’s dual-world aesthetic. In the 2D storybook segments, effects have a more cartoonish quality, enhancing the illustrated feel, while the 3D sections incorporate realistic sounds that ground the fantastical elements in a semblance of reality. This attention to auditory detail further immerses players in the game’s unique setting. ​

While the game features occasional voice work, particularly from the narrator, some players might find themselves wishing for more extensive voice acting to further enrich character interactions. Nonetheless, the combination of expressive visuals and a dynamic soundtrack ensures that The Plucky Squire delivers a sensory experience that is both enchanting and memorable.

Final Thoughts

The Plucky Squire is a charming action-adventure that cleverly intertwines 2D and 3D gameplay, offering players a visually captivating journey through the vibrant world of Mojo and beyond. Its inventive mechanics, such as transitioning between storybook pages and the real world, provide a fresh take on traditional platforming and puzzle-solving. The game’s art direction is particularly noteworthy, seamlessly blending hand-drawn illustrations with three-dimensional environments to create a storybook aesthetic that is both nostalgic and innovative.

​

However, the game is not without its shortcomings. Some critics have pointed out that while the initial concept is strong, certain gameplay elements, particularly in the latter stages, may feel repetitive or underdeveloped. For instance, IGN noted that “after facing a final boss that also goes on a phase too long, I was ready to be done before the credits even started rolling.” Additionally, the narrative, while endearing, follows a fairly predictable trajectory that doesn’t stray far from conventional hero-villain tropes.

Despite these critiques, The Plucky Squire has been well-received for its creativity and charm. The game offers a unique experience that appeals to both younger audiences and those young at heart, making it a delightful addition to the action-adventure genre. Its blend of art styles, coupled with engaging mini-games and puzzles, ensures that players remain entertained throughout the journey.

​

In conclusion, while The Plucky Squire may not revolutionize the genre, it stands out as a testament to the power of imagination in game design. Its heartfelt narrative, combined with innovative gameplay mechanics, makes it a worthwhile experience for those seeking a whimsical adventure that bridges the gap between the pages of a book and the world beyond.​

We prepared this review with a digital copy of The Plucky Squire for the PlayStation 5 version provided by Devolver Digital.